JDub
Mmm. Pie.
Fantastic! I was hoping I was over looking something! For some reason I thought the "speaker" volume was a master volume but it is in the voice menu. Derp.There are two different voice volume settings for when you have the mic plugged in and when you don't. Just turn the "Speaker" volume to 0 and the "Headset" volume to what you want and you'll never hear people unless you have your mic plugged in.