The Movie Thread

Then why haven't they banned Snow White, Shakespeare, Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, or any other book with magic/fantasy in them?

Harry Potter does NOT lead children to the occult, there's nothing ABOUT the occult in them. People who say there is haven't READ the damned things. They can't give any supporting evidence because they don't actually have any. This is what happens when you lead a life in fear.
 
Then why haven't they banned Snow White, Shakespeare, Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, or any other book with magic/fantasy in them?

Harry Potter does NOT lead children to the occult, there's nothing ABOUT the occult in them. People who say there is haven't READ the damned things. They can't give any supporting evidence because they don't actually have any. This is what happens when you lead a life in fear.


i totally agree with you. i dont believe that harry potter of all things leads to anything but a good read. bring up the snow white, shakespear etc, was a great argument. I tend to find its the really religious people that have an issue with this. not knocking religion, im just not religous i guess, but leave it to some people that interprut a book a certain way to over exagerate the simplist thing.
 
Anybody see Taken yet ? I wanted to see it this weekend. :D

[youtube=Taken Trailer]CvUxdQ4q-Lg[/youtube]

Wow thanks for the tip. That's now a must see.

Xenia Onatop/Jean Grey: Check.
Darkman/Qui Gon Jin: Check
Hot chick from lost: Check.
Lack of Will Smith: Check plus.

This movie gets a passing grade from me.

Harry potter leads kids into the occult? People probably think this because unlike the heroes of most fantasy productions the heroes are children who live in our world and learn to cast spells. As a somewhat religious person myself I have no problem with it. Most of the people who hop on these sorts of bandwagons are ignorant idiots who'll just as soon hop on any bandwagon that pulls up. Then again these people can't help that they're idiots and a lot of powerful people have a lot of money invested in making them believe the world is eroding under their feet. Some people just have sticks up their asses, and not the kind you use to play Quidditch. Taking the time to read the books would allay any fears, and letting kids read them should only lead to an appreciation of reading.

Books VS Movies: Well a movie's a lot quicker, but if we're talking about the movie version of a book then books all the way. I hate what hollywood does to good books. Watch the theatrical release ending to bladerunner and you'll see what I'm talking about. Sure, eventually that mistake was rectified, but the majority never are. I also read Jurassic park before it was ever a movie, The lawyer, Genaro was one of my favorite characters, in the book he's just a man trying to get back to his family who kills a pack of raptors in their den with a lead pipe, marches miles on a broken leg evading carnivorous pursuers, saves comely young virgins from the altars of snake-cults and blows a Tyrannosaurus Rex off the top of Nakatomi tower. Did I mention this Tyrannosaurus was flying an f-14 and gloating in your least favorite foreign accent? Yeah. Flash forward to the movie and he's just a cowardly, slimy comic foil for anybody who was sick to hell of the OJ Simpson trial.

I suppose as an author having your book made into a movie would be something of a mixed blessing. On the one had you can't beat the exposure a movie can lend your work, on the other a poorly handled adaptation might not be something you generally want people to see. Then you might run into a scenario where people love the movie based on your book but the story was so badly truncated or altered that you despise it for it's success.

So what am I trying to say? Hell if I know. Maybe if you're not much of a reader, go ahead and go see the movie, nothing's wrong with that. But you know, you might like the book if you tried it and movie adaptations aren't any kind of substitute. Usually they're more like a primer. It's also amazing how dumb screen writers usually think you are. Also nice work getting to the bottom of this post.

Also Mickey Roarke was nominated last night for an academy award for his performance in the wrestler. I been saying he'll take it. It's all coming together.
 
Edit: Its eternal sunshine of the spotless mind....not on..lol. And that movie is a plus or a HARD minus depending on your mood. That is the type of movie that you can watch and be a great movie on one day and the most depressing shit you've ever seen on another. I wonder what the suicide rate caused by ppl watching that movie after a break-up is.... ....

Hahaha harsh fanboyism fail. I've only seen it once though. You're right, it's really depressing. I tried to watch it again but I couldn't because I knew what was going to happen. That's just how good it is.
 
Hahaha harsh fanboyism fail. I've only seen it once though. You're right, it's really depressing. I tried to watch it again but I couldn't because I knew what was going to happen. That's just how good it is.

actually same... I only saw it once and don't really want to see it again honestly (but it was good albeit depressing). I'm like that with most movies anyway. Some people like watching movies again and again but I really have a hard time doing that anymore (its one thing when you watch star wars 100 times when you are eight...another when your 18 or 20 or 30..)
 
Back
Top