Kenjitsu_Hokori
[10] Knight
You seem to think that a 10% ratio of GOOD is uncommon or bad when it's the same with EVERYTHING EVER.
This is literally a law (not literally), Sturgeon's Law "ninety percent of everything is crap" . This is a THING, a thing that's existed for years and years. Even back in the day of ANIME this was true. I honestly don't think you've seen enough anime my man.
I'm actually against this law though that 90% of everything is mediocre because i have a high tolerance for stuff and have an incredible amount of patience.
Moe and Ecchi are just genres, incredibly popular right now sure but it's just a thing. I don't dislike any genre, that's the key here. I like everything on it's base idea level, it's up to the writers and directors to make it good. It can be about anything.
K-ON btw is good, not FANTASTIC, but good. WHY? Because it's actually somewhat well written. Add that to decent comedy, amazing animation quality (KyoAni is godlike of course), good music scores.... also bad ones.... and you have a good show. It's a simple matter.
Same with Lucky Star except replace good music with an incredible amount of anime references and remove any genre and boom a good show.
It's the-
![]()
of slice of life/school comedy shows
Key thing in your sentence from what I read is you have high tolerance for a show with a limited time and thats where people will be different. I have been watching anime for a long time and i mean... a LONG time... to the point i think i watched it too long but im no master when it comes to the matter. We can agree to disagree im glad you gave K-on a chance and so did I and good lord that anime was a WASTE of my time and patience. Not only was it practically about nothing (girls making a band) it was poorly written (to me and this is very opinionated not law) and not in the slightest funny. Now KyoAni did a great job with haruhi but K-on no... just no...
We wont see eye to eye on this but one point i agree with you is yes anime has been ecchi/moe for years but it wasnt so blatant to the point it became retarded like it is now. But, as i said we will agree to disagree. This isnt a argument thread this is as it is named obligatory anime thread. I just wish to see my kenshin remake really lol but i aint holding my breath and hell ill try sailor moon series that is supposed to come out xD.